EU PNR could be great tool in fight against major crime

Written by William Louch on 8 December 2015 in Opinion
Opinion

The controversial PNR bill now strikes a perfect balance between security and privacy, says Timothy Kirkhope.

Recently Brussels, the home of the EU institutions, became the second capital city in Europe to implement emergency security measures, following the terror attacks in Paris that left 130 dead. 

The Paris atrocities, along with those in Mali, Beirut and Egypt, confirmed a major shift in ISIS's strategy, demonstrating their capability and commitment to exporting their uniquely brutal brand of violence to a global audience.

This new, aggressive strategy, combined with trained European jihadis returning unchecked from conflict zones, provides the greatest threat to European security in a generation. Combating the growing threat is rightly at the forefront of the political agenda.


RELATED CONTENT


Something that is frequently mentioned when discussing security is the controversial passenger name record (PNR) directive. This measure would enable the more systematic collection, use and retention of data on international airline passengers.

The proposal, which dates back to 2011, was initially rejected by the European Parliament's civil liberties committee in April 2013, which raised concerns over its necessity, proportionality and the danger it poses to our fundamental rights. The Charlie Hebdo attacks in January this year thrust PNR back into the spotlight. 

Parliament committed in January to finalising an EU PNR directive by the end of 2015. Slow progress towards this goal has been made with negotiations between Council, Commission and Parliament currently underway.

However, given the new security context, there have been renewed calls to finalise the directive.  Bernard Cazeneuve and Theresa May, Security and Justice Ministers for France and the UK respectively, have reiterated these calls. May called for "immediate progress" on the PNR directive, saying "the negotiation has taken too long. They must be concluded."

Cazeneuve agreed, urging MEPs to waive their objections; "Not a single EU citizen will understand why the Parliament continues blocking this essential tool".

Tasked with steering PNR through this minefi eld of confl icting interests is Parliament's rapporteur for the report, ECR group MEP Timothy Kirkhope.

Kirkhope remains staunchly supportive of the legislation, telling the Parliament Magazine that; "The introduction of an EU PNR system will definitely enhance our capability to prevent major crime and terrorism."

Kirkhope acknowledged the need to strike a balance between security and privacy, something he feels the PNR report does. He said he believes that, "the issues of data protection and security must be looked at together and a balance struck; I believe my PNR does exactly that."

He highlighted the emphasis placed on striking a balance throughout the process, saying; "We have spent a considerable amount of time and trouble in finding the right balance between the needs for greater and more up to date security while protecting privacy in a constantly moving technological atmosphere."

He concluded; "Time will tell if my proposals really make a difference but I sincerely believe they will."

 

About the author

William Louch is a former editorial assistant for the Parliament Magazine

Interested in this content?

Sign up to our free daily email bulletins.

 

Share this page

Tags

Categories

Related Articles

Charles Tannock: UK must continue to cooperate with EU on security issues
17 October 2017

UK MEP Charles Tannock has told a conference that security “must remain a priority” in the future relationship between the UK and EU.

Juncker and May fail to impress after latest Brexit meeting
17 October 2017

MEPs have been left unimpressed by the outcome of a meeting in Brussels on Monday between UK Prime Minister Theresa May and European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker.

Claude Moraes: UK must provide further clarity on post-Brexit security cooperation
16 October 2017

As UK Prime Minister Theresa May made a fresh bid to end the Brexit deadlock, senior Labour MEP Claude Moraes has called for further clarity on the UK’s plans to quit the EU.

Related Partner Content

European Maritime Day: EU must address issue of flags of convenience
12 May 2016

A primary condition for quality European shipping is the prevention of unfair competition, argues Philippe Alfonso.

 

What Europe can do to resolve the Qatar crisis
20 July 2017

If Europe is serious about fighting terrorism and extremism, the institutions of the EU need to be more actively engaged in the current situation involving Qatar, argues Richard Burchill.

The need to counter extremist propaganda more effectively
13 December 2016

There are different reasons why people believe in extremist ideologies or join extremist groups, explains Alexander Ritzmann.