Disappointment reigns after EU summit fails to deliver on carbon neutrality goal
Experts have expressed disappointment with the outcome of a summit of EU leaders last week which failed to reach agreement on a “carbon-neutral” energy mix by 2050.
Central and Eastern European countries blocked a planned EU pledge to cut carbon emissions to net zero by 2050 at the summit in Brussels.
Four Member States - Poland, Hungary, Estonia and the Czech Republic - refused to support summit conclusions that would have sent a signal of intent from the EU to meet the Paris climate agreement to limit global warning to 1.5 degrees.
However, the failure to agree does not prevent individual EU countries from setting their own targets.
Speaking at a conference in Brussels on Friday, James Watson, Secretary General of Eurogas, said, “We were watching the outcome of this issue at the summit very closely and, ultimately, I think it is just a matter of time. For now, the can has been kicked down the road with some Member States still holding out.”
“However, the issue [of carbon neutrality] has not gone away and some big Member States like Germany, France and Italy, are still in favour. Generally, they usually get their way in the end.”
He added, “They did not get their way this time but, maybe, insufficient preparation was done ahead of the summit. The reality is that, whether it is at EU or national level, this [carbon neutrality] is going to happen.”
He was speaking at an event on “decarbonising Europe’s energy system with hydrogen”, organised by Zukunft ERDGAS, a gas industry lobby initiative.
“The reality is that, whether it is at EU or national level, this [carbon neutrality] is going to happen” James Watson, Secretary General of Eurogas
The meeting was told that a European energy system that relies not only on renewable energies but also on “green gases” such as decarbonised natural gas and renewable gas, is “more resilient and thus better suited to reach the EU's climate targets.”
This was the key message to emerge from a report presented to the conference called "Hydrogen from natural gas - The key to deep decarbonisation" and authored by the consultancy firm Pöyry.
The report was commissioned by ERDGAS, the German initiative.
The event heard that the European Commission has a “clear” vision: by 2050 the European community wants to achieve climate neutrality.
The long-term strategy adopted at the end of 2018, entitled "A Clean Planet for All", seeks to ensure that this transition is “socially fair.”
At the same time, the Commission wants to enhance the competitiveness of EU economy and industry.
Another speaker, Timm Kehler, chairman of Zukunft ERDGAS, said, “The climate challenge cannot be solved at a national level. What we need is a climate-friendly, resilient European energy system. The course for it must be set in Brussels now.”
“Green gas must be part of the solution because it can use existing infrastructures and applications and significantly reduce the costs and risks of the energy system’s transformation.”
“[EU] leaders have failed to agree on how soon to phase-out fossil fuels and bring emissions down to zero. We are calling on them to show leadership and act urgently on climate and ecosystem collapse in the next five years to transition towards a sustainable and just Europe” Jagoda Munic, Director of Friends of the Earth Europe
He added, “In order to establish a market for it, we need a clear target for green gas that includes hydrogen from natural gas and renewable gas from electrolysis as well as biogas. The industry needs to start developing these promising green gas technologies today. To do this, they need a reliable framework.”
Further reaction to the EU summit came from Jagoda Munic, director of Friends of the Earth Europe, who said: "The EU’s strategic agenda for the next five years recognises that building a climate-neutral, green and social Europe must be a priority, as demanded by millions in the streets.”
“However, leaders have failed to agree how soon to phase-out fossil fuels and bring emissions down to zero. We are calling on them to show leadership and act urgently on climate and ecosystem collapse in the next five years to transition towards a sustainable and just Europe,” she added.
Elsewhere, UK MEP Anthea McIntyre has welcomed the unveiling of a hydrogen-powered railway train which has been developed in her region.
McIntyre, Conservative spokesman on employment in Parliament, hailed the launch as "a key pointer to our greener future".
She spoke as the train, called the Hydrogen Hero, the UK’s first fully operating hydrogen train, was unveiled by Birmingham University's Birmingham Centre for Rail Research and Education (BCRRE).
McIntyre said, "Hydrogen fuel cell technology means that potentially carbon-free trains can replace diesel on our lines without electrification. It creates electricity from oxygen in the air and the only by-product is water.”
“The train on show was a scaled-down version, but I understand the design is ready right now to develop for full-size, full-scale production."
She added, "This is a key pointer to how our transport can be cleaner and greener … and I am so proud that it has been developed and showcased right here in the West Midlands. This is a place where cutting edge science works alongside manufacturing know-how and that is a powerful combination."
Much of the common sense thinking behind the circular economy already drives the home appliance industry says Paolo Falcioni.
The great advantage of Life Cycle Analysis is its ability to discover areas of weakness and improve upon them, explains Henri Colens.
EU policymakers need to set a new course that allows a genuine and innovative sustainability agenda to play its part in boosting economic recovery, argues Karl-H. Foerster.