European Commission’s cancer plans called into question at high-level summit
Europe's leading cancer groups have criticised the European Commission for its handling of the EU “mission” to cure cancer.
Patients remain outside of the cancer consultation process and the “moon-shot” approach is not an effective model for fighting cancer.
This was one of the conclusions reached by a panel of experts at the European Cancer Organisation (ECCO) Summit in Brussels on Thursday, where the issue of curing cancer was put under the microscope.
Curing cancer is one of five “missions” that Horizon Europe, Europe’s next research funding programme, will aim to address, starting in 2021. These missions are portfolios rather than single policy goals, with the aim of promoting research and innovation partnerships led by “Mission Boards” comprised of key stakeholders.
European Commission President-elect Ursula von der Leyen has also highlighted the need for a so-called Action Plan for Cancer.
A Commission representative, Dr Jan Willem van de Loo, was at the summit to present how the mission for cancer, to be led by former Nobel Prize-winner, Harald zur Hausen, would develop in the run-up to the launch of Horizon Europe.
The Commission official explained that the goal is to make the biggest societal impact, saying “the missions are not about science or research; they’re about much more than this. It’s not just about producing more data and project results.”
Nevertheless, summit attendees were almost unanimous in their disappointment with the makeup of the EU’s Horizon Europe Cancer Mission board in a resolution.
Moderator Professor Mark Lawler took aim at the EU for omitting patient representatives from the board, saying, “I’m disappointed to hear there isn’t a cancer sufferer on the cancer moonshot board.”
“If you have money for a mission and you’re going to use it wisely, you don’t make a broad declaration that Europe is going to cure cancer, because that’s a fairly silly thing to say” Harold Varmus, Nobel Prize-winner
The missions have taken inspiration from the US approach, such as the 1969 moon landing itself, and more recently with former US Vice-President Joe Biden launching the “Cancer Moonshot”.
Asked about von der Leyen’s Action Plan for Cancer, the Commission’s Dr van de Loo said, “we’ll have to wait and see”.
Meanwhile, moderator Professor Mark Lawler appeared less than impressed with the approach, asking, “Do we really want to shoot for the moon? It does not necessarily follow that the US model should be mirrored in a European Cancer Moonshot.”
Other panellists were also quick to pour cold water on EU’s “moon-shot” approach, with one quoting another former Nobel Prize-winner, Harold Varmus, who said “If you have money for a mission and you’re going to use it wisely, you don’t make a broad declaration that Europe is going to cure cancer, because that’s a fairly silly thing to say”.
For cancer experts, inequality in cancer treatment across Europe is also a significant concern.
“We need comprehensive cancer centres in every country, and they should be connected in a network. These need access to research and innovation to cures found in other countries” Professor Thierry Philip, President of OECI
Asked by the moderator how to address inequality, Professor Thierry Philip, President of OECI, said “We need comprehensive cancer centres in every country, and they should be connected in a network. These need access to research and innovation to cures found in other countries.”
Professor Lawler instead called for a “groundshot” for improving cancer treatment and care.
He stressed the need to put patients front and centre when it comes to reviewing and improving the way cancer is dealt with, especially when it comes to the EU’s cancer mission, saying “patients should be leaders, we need to change the way we do things.”
MEP and oncology professor, Véronique Trillet-Lenoir, said she appreciated the opportunity to hear about the EU’s fight against cancer and agreed that patients should always be included in strategies to this end.
The Renew Europe deputy has worked in oncology for 40 years and recently joined the MEPs Against Cancer European Parliament intergroup.
“Patients should be leaders, we need to change the way we do things” Professor Mark Lawler, Queen’s University Belfast
Providing a political perspective, the deputy said her first act as an MEP was to submit an amendment that would guarantee funding for von der Leyen’s roadmap to fight cancer, adding “I will make sure there will be a budget for this.”
Looking forward, Trillet-Lenoir said she will be given the floor next week in Strasbourg to underline the urgency of fighting cancer, while later this month she will also question the candidate for European Health Commissioner, Stella Kyriakides, on her plans to improve access to innovative therapies for cancer patients.
Outcomes of the H2020 EUREST-PLUS project will be presented on October 18, 2018 at the European Parliament in Brussels
Childhood cancer care continues to suffer from widespread inequalities, says Pamela Kearns.
Every fire victim is one too many, writes Quentin de Hults.