Saudi executions must not be catalyst for further catastrophe, warns senior MEP

Written by Richard Howitt on 11 January 2016 in Opinion
Opinion

The EU must ensure its counter-terrorism relationship with the Gulf states doesn't detract from its human rights obligations, argues Richard Howitt.

A Bahraini protester carries a poster of Saudi Shiite cleric Sheikh Nimr al-Nimr during a demonstration in Sitra, Bahrain, Friday, Jan. 8, 2016

Saudi Arabia's execution of 47 prisoners for offences of terrorism and "breaking allegiance with the ruler" flies in the face of the worldwide campaign against the death penalty, in which the European Union plays the leading role.

European efforts towards conflict resolution in Syria and across the Middle East and North Africa have also suffered a huge setback, in the serious breakdown in already fractious relations between the Saudis and Iran which has resulted.

The first priority for the EU must be renewed efforts to ensure that the close ties that exist between European countries and Saudi Arabia are used to promote genuine respect for human rights.


RELATED CONTENT


My own country, the UK, has failed to properly criticise Saudi Arabia for its actions, calling the executions merely "disappointing". The British government has excluded Saudi Arabia in its strategy document identifying 65 countries with whom to lobby against continued use of the death penalty. 

I back calls by my national MP colleague Andy Slaughter, Labour shadow human rights minister, for the UK government to publish and rethink the extent of its memorandum of understanding with Saudi Arabia.

At the European level, serious questions have to be asked about the agreement on counter-terrorism cooperation between the EU and the Gulf states. International human rights groups say at least some of those executed by Saudi Arabia have been political dissidents rather than terrorists, convicted by closed trials which do not meet international standards. 

Additionally, an independent legal opinion over civilian casualties caused by the bombing of Yemen, suggests EU countries are continuing to sell arms to Saudi Arabia in breach of the EU's code of conduct on arms exports.

The EU must urgently review whether our own human rights obligations are being fully respected in both cases, and to act accordingly.

Second, the severing of diplomatic relations with Iran by Saudi Arabia, and followed by other Gulf states, gravely impedes international efforts to work together on resolving the crises in Syria and elsewhere in the region.

The attack on the Saudi Arabian embassy in Tehran was unacceptable, but was condemned by the Iranians themselves. This weekend's Arab League statement making a further one-sided condemnation simply deepens the rift, and can only further aggravate the alarming rise of Shia-Sunni sectarianism. This could fuel further conflict within the countries of the region as well as between them.

For Europe, the consequence will be more conflict on our doorstep, more refugee movements, and more recruits to ISIS/Da'esh.

The task for European diplomacy to seek to de-escalate tensions between Tehran and Riyadh has simultaneously become more difficult but more urgent. The EU should not cut ties to Saudi Arabia, but neither should we be deflected from full implementation of the nuclear agreement with Iran.

However difficult it might seem today, Europe must not lessen efforts to get all sides around the table to create a peace process for Syria. These executions must be condemned, but they do not have to be a catalyst for further catastrophe.

And we can show Saudi Arabia, Iran and all countries in the world who continue to use the death penalty, that Europe is genuinely open to all interests in the world in the cause of peace and development, but that we will not compromise on principles of respect for human rights.

About the author

Richard Howitt (S&D, UK) is a member of Parliament's human rights subcommittee

Interested in this content?

Sign up to our free daily email bulletins.

 

Share this page

Tags

Categories

Related Articles

Jens Stoltenberg on the cover of PM 445 Issue 445 | 05 December 2016
5 December 2016

Interview with Jens Stoltenberg, Energy Efficiency, EU-Algeria, Antimicrobial Resistance, EU-Bangladesh, Digital Skills, Gender Equality in Mental Health, 5 questions with Ulrike Lunacek and more...

UK Supreme Court UK Supreme Court begins landmark Brexit hearing
5 December 2016

The UK's Supreme Court has begun a landmark legal hearing into whether the British Parliament's consent is required before official Brexit negotiations can begin.

Related Partner Content

Live animal exports PM+: EU disregarding its own rules on animal exports
31 March 2015

Live animals export trade is marring the EU's reputation as a leader in animal protection, says Olga Kikou.

EU-Montenegro European Parliament vote adds weight to calls for democratic reform in Montenegro
10 March 2016

Montenegrin Prime Minister Milo Đukanović’s western charm offensive is crumbling at his feet, argues Andrey Petrushinin.

A picture of the justice system The case for reforming the European arrest warrant: Alexander Adamescu vs. Romania
27 October 2016

The case of Alexander Adamescu underlines why the European arrest warrant needs urgent reform, argues Mitchell Belfer.