Populists flourish after financial crises - but they get found out in the end

Written by Daniel Hannan on 25 November 2016

Daniel Hannan | Photo credit: European Parliament audiovisual


Populists flourish after financial crises - but they get found out in the end, writes Daniel Hannan.

This article was originally published on Conservative Home.

It started with the credit crunch. Donald Trump, Bernie Sanders, Geert Wilders, Marine Le Pen, Jeremy Corbyn, Syriza, Podemos, the SNP - they're all, in their various ways, a delayed reaction to the 2008 crash.

Financial crises are not like ordinary economic contractions. For one thing, they last a lot longer - typically eight years, according to a study by the economists Carmen Reinhart and Kennet Rogoff. 

Eight years is a long time for resentment to build among the people (usually the majority of the population) who have suffered. Their resentment is heightened by a sense that the system is rigged against them: that they are working to support a parasite class of politicians and rich bankers.


RELATED CONTENT


Rich bankers are always going to be more unpopular than rich footballers or rich property developers. This is partly because the human brain is ill-adapted to the complexities of a modern market economy. We still have the instincts and intuitions of Pleistocene hunger-gatherers. 

We find it hard to understand that an intangible thing can have as much worth as a material one. How can moving money about on a computer be real work, in the same sense as soldering metal or driving a combine harvester? How can the banker be paid so much more than the welder or the farmer?

Every age struggles to understand that optimising the allocation of capital is a valuable service. In ancient and in mediaeval times, merchants were disdained as ignoble. Prices were regulated on grounds that objects had a "natural" value. 

Usury and speculation were condemned, often criminalised. Even in the twentieth century, it was easy enough to whip up a storm against markets: fascists, revolutionary socialists and anti-colonialists sounded remarkably similar when they railed against decadent western capitalism.

We in the west, the chief beneficiaries of that system, are generally more relaxed about it. As long as our own salaries are rising, we don't much mind about bankers' bonuses. 

But when growth falters, we become resentful. And when we see low and medium-earners being taxed to rescue wealthy bankers and bondholders from the consequences of their own errors, our resentment turns to rage.

"The thing that hath been, it is that which shall be," King Solomon tells us, "and there is no new thing under the sun." Trump and Corbyn are manifestations of an age-old phenomenon: the populist backlash that follows a banking meltdown.

A group of German economists has studied every financial crisis in the West since 1870, and found that, on average, populist and authoritarian parties surge by around 30 per cent as the economic consequences play out. The beneficiaries are those who best articulate the fury of the people whose incomes are stagnating.

To articulate that fury, of course, they need to find someone to yell about. The identity of that someone is, in a sense, secondary. Donald Trump blames immigrants, Alexis Tsipras blames Germans, Marine Le Pen blames Muslims. (Demagogues rarely blame Jews these days, at least not openly, though populist movements of both left and right often have an anti-Semitic tinge.)

The choice of target, though, matters less than the fact of there being a target. Never mind that illegal immigration into the United States is lower today than it was before the crash. 

Never mind that Germans keep sending their taxes to Greece when all they get back are Nazi-themed insults. In the aftermath of a crash, people aren't looking for context; they're looking for politicians who can verbalise their grievances.

Now for a hard thing that needs saying. Much of the reaction to the 2008 collapse was justified. Politicians raised a trillion dollars in taxation and used it to… well, no one is exactly sure where it went. 

Central banks around the world cut interest rates and printed more money, pushing up the price of property and assets. In consequence, people who owned shares and houses - what Marxists would call rentiers – prospered while wage-earners fell behind. You don't have to be on the Left to find this outrageous.

The people who fell behind felt insulted as well as injured. Seeing a stagnation in your income is bad enough. But when you're simultaneously dismissed as a racist oaf by the people who are doing well, you want to hit back. 

The tragedy is that the policies advocated by most populists - protectionism, higher spending, state intervention - serve to harm the voters from whom they draw their chief support. That's why, in the end, populists fizzle out, as the lamentable Tsipras, who started the cycle earlier than most, is doing in Greece.

In other countries it will take longer. But it will happen. Anger is a powerful emotion; but it carries us only so far. In the end, we want something more wholesome.

About the author

Daniel Hannan (ECR, UK) is a Vice-Chair of Parliament's delegation to the ACP-EU joint parliamentary assembly

Share this page

Tags

Categories

Comments

ShoellsVik3613

Submitted on 12 January, 2017 - 18:22
<a href=http://gartsiniya-kambodzhiyskaya-dlya-pohudeniya.cu.cc><img>http://gartsiniya-kambodzhiyskaya-dlya-pohudeniya.cu.cc/pics/gartsiniya-kambodzhiyskaya-dlya-pohudeniya.png</img></a> <a href=http://gartsiniya-kambodzhiyskaya-dlya-pohudeniya.cu.cc/gartsiniya-tsena/evalar-gartsiniya-tsena.php>эвалар гарциния цена</a> Стабилизируется настроение на фоне адекватного эмоционального фона. Гарциния камбоджийская оказывает множество действии на процесс регуляции веса: - тормозит новообразование жира, - нормализует уровень сахара в крови, - повышает иммунитет человека при систематическом употреблении. Принимала его как рекомендовала инструкция. Не скажу, что на таком питании очень легко сидеть, нет. Прием других лекарств На настоящий момент нет сведений о взаимодействии Цитримакса с другими лекарственными препаратами. В первом случае блокируется действие фермента, расщепляющего жир. Но, помните: перед употреблением любых биодобавок нужно проконсультироваться с эндокринологом или терапевтом. Среди таких препаратов лекарства для лечения астмы, аллергии и диабета. Основным компонентом препарата является экстракт... Плоды золотого мандарина стимулируют обменные процессы Вашего организма. Я буду говорить только в присутствии своего авокад... Так, были созданы две группы людей с явными проблемами ожирения. Буду заказывать ещё и рекомендую другим. <a href=http://gartsiniya-kambodzhiyskaya-dlya-pohudeniya.cu.cc/kambodzhiyskaya-gartsiniya/gartsiniya-kambodzhiyskaya-evalar-sostav.php>гарциния камбоджийская эвалар состав</a> В любом случае нужно рассчитать какое количество препарата соответствует суточной дозе и разделить его на три приема. Препарат помогает значительно снизить аппетит.... Эвалар создал замечательный продукт доступный всем,к тому же он недорогой и действительно… без эффекта Все это конечно хорошо, что экстракт Гарцинии, якобы такой полезный при похудании очень поможет, только все это красиво когда аннотации и рекламные проспекты читаешь. В странах Индокитая растение используется при изготовлении лекарств от дизентерии, глистов, расстройств и отравлений кишечника. Пока результат за несколько дней. Побочные эффекты у таблеток тоже имеются, причем довольно неожиданные.. Последние исследования получились неоднозначными, но очень интересными. Или лучше по отдельности,месяц один препарат потом месяц другой? Он является превосходным средством, защищающим печень от токсинов и канцерогенных метаболитов, в частности при алкогольной интоксикации. Мы дарим Вам промокод со скидкой на следующую покупку. Тут на меня нашло вдохновение, я начала ещё крутить обруч, талия нарисовалась практически сразу. Кроме того,обладает антисептическими свойствами, сравнимыми со свойствами эвкалипта. Вместе с гарцинией камбоджийской для похудения можно принимать антибиотики, прописанные врачом, а также другие препараты.

Related Articles

EU leaders consider Theresa May's citizens' rights offer
23 June 2017

EU leaders on Friday were digesting an offer from UK Prime Minister Theresa May that would allow about three million EU citizens living in the UK to stay after Brexit.

The Brexit talks have begun - what now?
23 June 2017

The Brexit talks are underway, but Teams Barnier and Davis have a long and complicated road ahead of them.